BOGO
Best sale Sale · no code needed
Abracadabra NYC sales and deals, October 2026
Ships same/next business dayStandard: 3 business daysNo signature required
Best sale: Buy 1 get 1 free, no code needed.
Abracadabra NYC sales
2 sales on now · no code neededBOGO
Sale · no code needed
Buy 2 get 1 free
Other ways to save at Abracadabra NYC
Rewards program
Shoppers can earn rewards with every purchase through the store's rewards program.
Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/rewards-program-page · checked Oct 2
Abracadabra NYC store facts
- Order ship time
- Orders ship the same or next business day, Monday through Friday, excluding holidays.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Standard shipping transit time
- Standard shipping typically arrives within 3 business days.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Signature not required
- Carriers do not require a signature, so packages are left at the address if no one is home.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- International customs fees
- Customers are solely responsible for any international shipping customs duties and charges.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Same-day delivery speed
- Same-day local delivery usually occurs within 2-3 hours, depending on inventory and order time.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- In-store pickup time
- Most items ordered online can be picked up from the store or warehouse within 24 hours.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Pickup grace period before store credit
- Unpicked-up orders are held 30 days, then canceled with a store credit issued for the sale amount, valid 60 days.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Pickup item restocking
- Pickup order items not collected within 90 days of purchase will be restocked.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Return/exchange eligibility window
- For damaged, defective, or missing items, shoppers must email within 48 hours of receiving the package to be eligible for a refund or exchange.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Return shipping cost
- Customers pay their own return shipping costs, which are non-refundable and deducted from any refund.Source: abracadabranyc.com/policies/refund-policy · checked Oct 2
- Shipping insurance recommendation
- For returns of items over $75, the store recommends trackable shipping or insurance since delivery isn't guaranteed.Source: abracadabranyc.com/policies/refund-policy · checked Oct 2
- Customer service contact
- Customers can call 212-627-5194 or use live chat during normal business hours for help.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Rental period length
- A typical costume or prop rental period lasts 3 days, covering pick up, event day, and return day.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Pickup within 24 hours
- Most items may be ordered online and picked up within 24 hours of placing your order.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Two pickup locations
- There are two locations available for pickup, one in New York and one in New Jersey.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- 30-day pickup grace period
- If an order is not picked up within 30 days, it will be cancelled and you'll receive a store credit for the sale amount.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Store credit valid 60 days
- Store credit issued for cancelled orders is valid for 60 days from the date it's issued.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- 48-hour damage report window
- If an item arrives damaged, defective, or missing parts, customers must email within 48 hours of receiving the package to be eligible for an exchange or refund.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Customer pays return shipping
- Customers are responsible for paying their own shipping costs to return an item, and shipping costs are non-refundable.Source: abracadabranyc.com/policies/refund-policy · checked Oct 2
- Insure returns over $75
- For items being returned that are worth over $75, customers should consider trackable shipping or insurance since the store doesn't guarantee receipt of the returned item.Source: abracadabranyc.com/policies/refund-policy · checked Oct 2
- Rental period is 3 days
- A typical costume or prop rental period lasts 3 days, covering pick up day, event day, and return day.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- October rental extension
- In October, the store offers an extended rental period at no additional charge.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- October deposits charged not authorized
- During October, security deposits are charged, not just authorized, to the credit card due to the extended rental period.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Standard shipping ~3 business days
- Standard shipping typically arrives in 3 business days.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Orders ship same/next business day
- All orders ship the same or next business day, Monday through Friday, excluding holidays.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- No signature required
- The store's carriers do not require a signature, so packages are left at the address if no one is home.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Pickup restocked after 90 days
- Pickup order items not collected within 90 days of the original purchase date will be restocked.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Same-day delivery window
- Same-day local delivery usually occurs within 2-3 hours, subject to inventory and order time.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Customer service phone number
- Customers can call 212-627-5194 for immediate assistance or live chat during normal business hours.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Order held 30 days
- Orders are held for 30 days after being fulfilled, then canceled and refunded as store credit.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Store credit valid 60 days
- Store credit issued for unpicked-up orders is valid for 60 days after being issued.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Items restocked after 90 days
- Pickup order items not collected within 90 days of the original purchase date will be restocked.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- 48 hours to report damage
- Shoppers must email about damaged, defective, or missing items within 48 hours of receiving the package to be eligible for a refund or exchange.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Typical rental period 3 days
- A typical costume or prop rental period lasts 3 days, covering pick up, the event day, and return day.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Free extended October rental
- During October, the store offers an extended rental period at no additional charge, letting you return costumes up to a week after Halloween.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- October deposits charged not authorized
- During October, security deposits are charged (not just authorized) to the credit card due to the extended rental period, and refunded in full upon undamaged return.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/faq · checked Oct 2
- Same-day delivery in 2-3 hours
- Same-day local delivery usually occurs within 2-3 hours for select areas near NYC or Wall, NJ, subject to inventory and order time.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
- Customer pays customs duties
- For international shipping, the customer is solely responsible for any customs duties, fees, and charges.Source: abracadabranyc.com/pages/shipping-pick-up-info · checked Oct 2
Abracadabra NYC questions
Does Abracadabra NYC have a current discount or promo?
Yes, the store currently offers buy 1 get 1 free.
Is there a loyalty or rewards program?
Yes, shoppers earn rewards with every purchase through the store's rewards program.
Can I avoid shipping costs by picking up my order?
Most items ordered online can be picked up within 24 hours at either the New York or New Jersey location, which lets you skip shipping fees. If you don't pick it up within 30 days, the order is canceled and you get store credit for the sale amount, valid for 60 days.
How fast is shipping if I don't pick up in store?
Orders ship the same or next business day, Monday through Friday, and standard shipping typically arrives within 3 business days. Same-day local delivery near NYC or Wall, NJ, usually takes just 2-3 hours depending on inventory.
Are there extra savings on costume rentals in October?
Yes, in October the store offers an extended rental period at no additional charge, letting you return costumes up to a week after Halloween. During this time, the full security deposit is charged to your card instead of just authorized, and it's refunded in full once the item is returned undamaged.
What should I do if my order arrives damaged or wrong?
Email the store within 48 hours of receiving the package to stay eligible for a refund or exchange.
About saving at Abracadabra NYC
Abracadabra NYC makes it easy to save without hunting for a special code: the store's current offer is a straightforward buy 1 get 1 free deal, so stocking up on costumes, props, or gifts costs less per item right out of the gate. Beyond that, shoppers who sign up for the rewards program earn points on every purchase, which adds up to savings over time if you shop here more than once.
Timing and pickup choices matter too. Most online orders can be picked up within 24 hours at either the New York or New Jersey location, which skips shipping costs altogether. If you order online for delivery instead, standard shipping usually takes about 3 business days, and orders go out the same or next business day Monday through Friday. Same-day local delivery near NYC or Wall, NJ, can land in as little as 2-3 hours depending on inventory, which is handy if you need something fast and want to avoid a shipping charge entirely.
October shoppers get an extra perk: costume and prop rentals come with an extended return window at no added cost, giving you until about a week after Halloween to bring items back. Just know that during this period, the store charges the full security deposit to your card instead of just holding it, refunding it once the item comes back undamaged.
A few housekeeping details help protect your wallet, too. If you don't pick up an order within 30 days, it gets canceled and turned into store credit good for 60 days, and anything left unclaimed past 90 days gets restocked. If something arrives damaged or wrong, email the store within 48 hours of delivery to stay eligible for a refund or exchange.
Similar stores
How we confirm Abracadabra NYC codes
- Real orders: Abracadabra NYC reports which code was used on each order placed through our links. Codes that worked go to the top.
- Where it came from: every code shows its source, whether Abracadabra NYC issued it or shoppers shared it.
- Your answers: "Did it work?" after you use a code. We count answers but trust orders more.